AAAI-98 PAPER REVIEW FORM -- COMMENTS FOR THE AUTHOR(S)
PAPER CODE:
PAPER TITLE:
Significance:
-
Is the work reported important?
-
Does it advance the state of the art?
-
Does the paper stimulate discussion of important issues or alternative
points of view?
Originality:
-
Are the problems or approaches new?
-
Is this a novel combination of existing techniques?
-
Does the paper
-
Point out differences from related research?
-
Address a new problem or one that has not been studied in depth?
-
Introduce an interesting research paradigm?
-
Describe an innovative combination of ai techniques with ones from other
disciplines?
-
Introduce an idea that appears promising or might stimulate others to develop
promising alternatives?
Quality:
-
Is the paper technically sound?
-
Does it carefully evaluate the strengths and limitations of its contributions?
-
Are its claims backed up?
-
Does the paper offer a new form of evidence in support of or against a
well-known technique?
-
Does the paper back up a theoretical idea already in the literature with
experimental evidence?
-
Does it offer a theoretical analysis of prior experimental results?
Clarity:
-
Is the paper clearly written?
-
Does it motivate the research?
-
Does it describe the inputs, outputs, and basic algorithms employed?
-
Are the results described and evaluated?
-
Is the paper organized in a logical fashion?
-
Is the paper written in a manner that makes its content accessible to most
AI researchers?
Other comments for the author(s):